Kratom Vendors

Mystic Island Kratom Review: A Company Shrouded In Mystery

Mystic Island Kratoms is a South Pacific kratom vendor specializing in raw powder, proprietary blends, and customer-crafted “veteran” blends.

The brand has many positive reviews online, suggesting that the product has decent potency and quality. Unfortunately, there are no third-party lab results posted on the website, and there is no mention of lab testing even being done privately. This, along with other downsides, have many people questioning its reliability. 

Below, you’ll find an in-depth review of this company, including a discussion about its products, its business practices, its shipping and return policies, and more.

Written by Wade Paul
Last Updated 1 month ago

Wade Paul

Founder & Editor-In-Chief

Wade Paul is the founder and editor-in-chief at

Rating: 2

Aka GMP Certified no
Pricing $3.00 — $69.00
Verified Vendor

Mystic Island Kratom

2 / 5
Ranked 139 out of 190 vendors

There’s very little information on this company and no mention of lab tests. Unfortunately, we can’t score them very high due to the lack of transparency, among other things.

About the Company

Mystic Island Kratoms was founded in Wilmington, NC, where the brains behind the operation decided to focus on purchasing kratom in bulk and passing the savings on to the customer.

Unfortunately, there isn’t any information available about the founders or current owners of the company. This suggests a lack of transparency that is furthered by the fact that there is no third-party lab testing done on its products.

The About Us page also lacks any real information, other than a thank you to customers who have supported the business in the past. A lack of a mission statement or any apparent involvement in the kratom industry suggests that the company could exist solely for profit and not for a more worthwhile goal.

  • Wide selection
  • Positive online reviews
  • Accepts Bitcoin
  • Very affordable
  • No mention of third-party testing
  • Not AKA certified
  • Questionable quality
  • No returns or satisfaction guarantee
  • Lack of company information

Best Alternatives

Kona Kratom
Top Vendor

Kona Kratom


Enter KRATOM20 for 20% off

New Dawn Kratom
Top-Shelf Quality

New Dawn Kratom


Enter NDKKORG10 for 10% off

Star Kratom
Free Shipping

Star Kratom


Enter KRATOM15 for 15% off

Bulk Kratom Now
Best Bulk Deals

Bulk Kratom Now


Enter 10OFFKORG for 10% off

VIP Kratom
Top-Shelf Quality

VIP Kratom


Enter KRATOM10 for 10% off

Mystic Island Kratom Product Reviews

Mystic Island Kratom’s catalog consists of some rather confusing products. Rather than listing offerings by strain name or blend color, it assigns proprietary names to most of them. It offers “Originals” (single leaf strains), “Mystic Creatures” (kratom powder blends), “Mystic Gems” (finely powdered kratom blends), and Vet Blends (blends reportedly made by customers).

Best Kratom Powders

Kratom powder is the most widely available form of kratom and, by far, the most popular way to consume it. It’s made of crushed leaves from the kratom tree, and most users take it using the toss-and-wash method. Kratom powder is the most affordable way to purchase kratom, but some people pay more for other methods to avoid the herb’s bitter flavor.

Mystic Island Kratoms Red Bali Kratom Powder

This red vein kratom powder is a high-intensity strain that’s as strong as it is subtle. Its effects come on gradually and subtly, but once they do, you’ll be glad you’re not driving. This strain is well known for being high in the alkaloid 7-hydroxymitragynine, which is responsible for kratom’s sedative and pain-relieving capabilities. This strain is likely to leave you feeling intensely relaxed and free of pain.

Price: $4.00 for 25 grams, $10.00 for 75 grams, $18.00 for 125 grams, $28.00 for 250 grams, $42.00 for 500 grams, or $79.00 for 1,000 grams/1 kilogram

Mystic Island Kratoms Super Green Malay Kratom Powder

Super Green Malay is considered a “fast” strain that comes on quickly and doesn’t quit for upwards of four hours. This green vein kratom powder typically provides a subtle sense of warmth and vitality while serving as a stress-free pick-me-up. It can also provide a boost of energy and improve focus and concentration at lower doses.

Price: $4.00 for 25 grams, $10.00 for 75 grams, $18.00 for 125 grams, $28.00 for 250 grams, $42.00 for 500 grams, or $79.00 for 1,000 grams/1 kilogram

Mystic Island Kratoms White Maeng Da Kratom Powder

White Maeng Da is a popular Maeng Da variant because it combines the full-bodied fragrance of reds with the bold “fast” properties of green veins. White MD is known to be alleviating and invigorating at the same time, making it a good choice as an all-day kind of strain. Most users feel mild euphoria, a burst of clean energy, and improved mental acuity when taking this strain.

Price: $4.00 for 25 grams, $10.00 for 75 grams, $18.00 for 125 grams, $28.00 for 250 grams, $42.00 for 500 grams, or $79.00 for 1,000 grams/1 kilogram

Other Strains Offered by Mystic Island Kratoms

Mystic Island Kratoms offers a decent selection of strains, but it provides far more blends. Since most of the blends don’t include information about the strains contained within them, the list below will provide information for just the single-strain variants this company carries. All strains are available according to the same pricing model: $4.00 for 25 grams, $10.00 for 75 grams, $18.00 for 125 grams, $28.00 for 250 grams, $42.00 for 500 grams, or $79.00 for 1,000 grams/1 kilogram.


These gems are the biggest sellers at this vendor’s online store, and it’s easy to see why. These are some funky blends.

1. Aquamarine

Aquamarine is a blend of red and white vein powder that is ideal for daytime use. Although this seller’s claims about this mixture are a bit misleading, most users seem genuinely pleased with the uplifting effects.

2. Mystique 

Mystique isn’t for the unadventurous as it is this seller’s “mystery blend.” There isn’t much mystery to it (this is clearly a mix of reds and whites, possibly blended with gold and yellow vein kratom), but there’s plenty to marvel at all the same.

3. Sapphire

Sapphire is exactly as it’s advertised — a mixture of greens, reds, whites, and yellows that’s as pure as it is rejuvenating. A strong cup makes most users feel sharp and in charge.

All Mystic Gems start at the same meager prices as Originals, so you’ll always get a starter bag for three bucks and a kilo for $69.00.

Best Kratom Vet Blend of 2023

These folks value their customers so much that they invite them to submit user feedback and ideas for specialty blends. 

In the case of the wildly popular Phatcracker, it is an exotic blend of Mystic Unicorn and Amethyst that was suggested to them by a user who goes by the handle u/Phatcracker.

The blend has a soft, fluffy texture and earthy fragrance. Phatcracker is a serene kratom blend that’s known for its temperance and positive vibes. This is a mixture of greens and reds, so keep that in mind if you have a sensitivity to either.

Is Mystic Island Kratoms Legit?

Mystic Island Kratoms is a legitimate company, but some users refuse to order from this vendor because of the lack of transparency and commitment to quality.

For starters, this company doesn’t post third-party lab results for its products, and it does not indicate on the website that it carries testing out at all. This is a massive red flag for most kratom users and sends most customers looking elsewhere for guaranteed potency and safety.

Mystic Island also isn’t accredited by the American Kratom Association (AKA) and has no return policy or customer satisfaction guarantee. While the low prices appeal to some customers, others see them as another sign of lacking quality.

None of these things instill confidence in buyers, so many people look elsewhere for quality kratom products.

What You Can Expect To Pay

Mystic Island Kratoms maintains incredibly low prices that are more affordable than you’ll find from most competitors. This entices some users to look beyond the lack of third-party testing and AKA certification, but others believe it’s just another sign that the quality isn’t there.

All powders — including single strains and blends — are offered according to the same pricing model:

  • $4.00 for 25 grams
  • $10.00 for 75 grams
  • $18.00 for 125 grams
  • $28.00 for 250 grams
  • $42.00 for 500 grams
  • $79.00 for 1,000 grams/1 kilogram

Accepted Payment Options

Mystic Island Kratoms lacks the variety of secure payment options that most users look for in a kratom vendor. It offers to invoice via email, although it’s unclear how those invoices can be paid.

Another option available is to pay for your kratom with Bitcoin, which offers a secure and anonymous way to buy kratom. Unfortunately, you won’t be able to pay with eCheck, ACH deposit, or credit card.

What Other Customers Say About This Brand

Mystic Island Kratoms has many reviews online, especially on Reddit, which is one of the more trusted sources for kratom vendor and product reviews.

Despite lacking testing to confirm potency and no AKA certification, Mystic Island Kratom maintains positive reviews. Some people have stated that kratom from this vendor has been more potent or had a more desirable effect than other online vendors. Others have said that it’s a bit average in effects, but nearly every review suggests that the quality is at least decent.

Shipping & Returns

Mystic Island Kratoms’ website states that it ships all orders via USPS. Most orders placed before 2 pm EST will be shipped out the same day, but customers should allow up to 48 hours for processing. Shipping is based on flat rates, depending on the weight of the products you purchase.

Unfortunately, Mystic Island does not have a return policy, and the website explicitly states that all sales are final. It does mention that it might be willing to offer a replacement product if you’re dissatisfied, but there are no guarantees.

Best Kratom Vendors: Alternatives

Most kratom users turn elsewhere for their products when they discover the lack of third-party testing, no AKA accreditation, and no return policy or satisfaction guarantee. The vendors below post third-party lab results online for all customers to see, are certified by the AKA, and have 30-day satisfaction guarantees to back up all of the products.

1. VIP Kratom

Aka GMP Certified yes
Pricing $40.00 — $125.00
Verified Vendor

VIP Kratom

4.85 / 5
Ranked 4 out of 190 vendors

VIP Kratom is the ideal online vendor for anyone looking for the highest-quality kratom money can buy. This company goes above and beyond to ensure you get precisely what you expect, and their powders and capsules are consistent, potent, and pure, repeatedly.

If you’re the kind of person that likes to shop around and experiment with new strains, VIP Kratom’s selection will wow you. Remember that they are more expensive than most of their competitors, but this should be expected, given the quality.


  • High-quality kratom
  • Powders and capsules available
  • Tested by third-party labs
  • Extensive selection


  • Pricier than most other options

2. Kona Kratom

Aka GMP Certified yes
Pricing $45.00 — $115.00
Verified Vendor

Kona Kratom

4.95 / 5
Ranked 1 out of 190 vendors

Kona Kratom is a very popular online vendor offering high-quality kratom products for exceptionally affordable prices. Their value is unmatched in the kratom industry.

You can always be sure of what you’re getting when you order, as they provide third-party lab results for everything they sell. That way, you can verify the potency and purity before you purchase.

They have a good selection of popular and uncommon strains, so most users can find something that suits them. However, you will have to wait a bit for your shipment, as they have slower shipping times than some other vendors.


  • High-quality kratom
  • Affordable
  • Excellent value
  • Third-party lab results available
  • Good selection


  • Slower shipping than other vendors

3. Star Kratom

Aka GMP Certified yes
Pricing $35 — $95
Verified Vendor

Star Kratom

4.9 / 5
Ranked 2 out of 190 vendors

Star Kratom carries high-quality products for a fraction of the price that other online vendors charge. They post third-party lab results for everything they sell on their website, and they maintain an unending commitment to quality and customer service.

The best part about this brand is its rapid shipping times. While they might not have the greatest selection of kratom powders out there, their ability to get what you order to your doorstep quickly is unrivaled.


  • High-quality products
  • Very affordable
  • Third-party lab results available
  • Rapid shipping


  • Smaller product selection than other brands

Final Thoughts: Remarkably Low Prices But Questionable Quality

Mystic Island Kratoms offers a decent selection of single-strain kratom powders and a massive array of kratom powder blends. While many online reviews state that the potency is acceptable, the company offers no third-party lab results and makes no mention of testing ever being completed on its products.

The lack of testing alongside the lack of AKA certification means that the potency is questionable, and the products could contain contaminants, including bacteria, heavy metals, pesticides, and other potentially harmful compounds.

If you’re comfortable ordering from a company that doesn’t back its products with lab tests, a return policy, or any satisfaction guarantee, the Red Bali powder is one of the more popular single-strain powders available from the site.

Trending Articles